Grading

How a seller earns its grade

A grade on this site is 6 readings of one seller's written terms, weighted and added up. Nothing else goes in: no sales figures, no star counts, no claims we cannot point to on the seller's own pages. Our three picks sit above each list; every other seller is placed by its grade alone.

Revised

1. Find the clause

For each term we find the page where the seller commits to it in writing: an order page, its terms of service, a refund policy, an FAQ or a help article.

  • The address of that page
  • The date it was read
  • The clause, kept on file in its own words

2. Weigh what matters to a buyer

Who does the following and the money-back terms carry a quarter of the grade each. Client orders and support follow, then refills and the password question, which almost every seller now gets right.

TermShare of the grade
Who does the following25%
Client orders15%
Password10%
Refund in writing25%
Top-ups after drops10%
Someone to answer15%

3. Silence drops out

If a seller writes nothing about a term, that term leaves its grade and the other weights grow to cover the gap. An unsaid refill window is not marked down as a missing one.

4. One word per band

Every grade out of 10 also gets a single word, so a long list can be read at a glance.

  • Top grade

    9.0 and up

  • Firm

    8.0 to 8.9

  • Fair

    7.0 to 7.9

  • Patchy

    6.0 to 6.9

  • Thin

    0.0 to 5.9

Read the list these rules produce

Every SMM panel and growth service we graded, top grade first.